How Do You Create Accessible Videos?
Of the two methods for creating accessible videos, captioning and describing, the process of captioning is more supported as evidenced by the number of tools available for producing and editing captions. On this page, we’ll begin by exploring a number of workflows for creating captioned videos, starting with the support that is built into many video editing applications. At the end, we’ll introduce tools currently available for describing video.
Note: The AEM Center does not endorse specific products. The lists on this page are intended to help you start your research into the world of captioning and description solutions. We hope the list of products that support captioning and audio description will continue to grow and we will do our best to keep these lists updated. If you would like us to consider additional tools, please share your recommendation with us via email at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Captioning Support in Video Editing Applications
The following video editing applications include captioning support in their content creation workflows (follow the links for specific instructions for working with captions in each application):
- Apple: Final Cut Pro X
- Adobe: Premiere Pro
- Techsmith: Camtasia
- Telestream: Screenflow (see below for information about its audio description feature)
Captioning with Automation Support
While automatically generated captions are of low quality, they can be transformed into high quality captions with some editing for accuracy and proper timing. Once your video has finished processing, you can edit YouTube's automatically generated captions by correcting errors and adjusting the timing of the individual caption clips.
Another option is to create a transcript and let YouTube add the time codes to make sure the video and the captions are in sync. The transcript can be created in one of two ways:
- Using YouTube’s transcribe and auto-sync feature. You will type the captions in a provided text field and then select “Set timings” when you are done to have YouTube convert the transcript text into properly timed captions. To make the process easier, YouTube can pause the video each time you start typing your transcript text.
- Using a tool such as Express Scribe to create a transcript file, then importing that file into YouTube to add the timings needed for captions.
With either method, accuracy will depend on the quality of the audio. For the best results the video should also be less than one hour long.
Microsoft’s Flipgrid also allows educators to turn on automatic captioning on a Grid (the equivalent of a YouTube channel). Unfortunately, at the time of writing it is not possible to edit these automatic captions.
Accessible Educational Materials (AEM)
Print- and technology-based educational materials designed to be usable across the widest range of individual variability.View in glossary
Inclusion of verbal or auditory descriptions of on-screen visuals intended to describe important details not contained from main audio output.View in glossary
CAST (Center for Applied Special Technology)
Non-profit organization that works to expand learning opportunities for all individuals through research and development.View in glossary
- It is available for Mac and Windows in both 32-bit and 64-bit versions (make sure to download the correct version for your operating system).
- It runs as a web app that works on most browsers.
- It has a built-in editor where the audio from a video can be transcribed and timed using a number of easy-to-learn keyboard shortcuts.
- It supports styling and placement for captions.
- It supports the importing of plain text transcripts or caption files in order to perform error correction (supported formats for import include WebVTT and SRT - the latter format is used on YouTube and many other video hosting services).
- It has support for exporting to popular caption file formats, including WebVTT, SRT, SCC and more.
CADET has a description feature, but it is only meant to identify the pauses in a video where descriptions will fit, and then provide description text to fit within those pauses. The result is a transcript with timing cues a human narrator can use to record a voice-over track.
Digital form or representation of a sound which may be used for non-visual access to text and images.View in glossary
Getting Started with CADET
CADET supports the following keyboard shortcuts:
- Control and Space to starts/stop playback and allow you to listen to the video
- Control and Comma to add a caption timecode
- Control and Period to add an end time at the previous caption (this indicates a pause in the video where no audio is present)
- Enter/Return twice to create a new caption row
Commercial Captioning Tools
MovieCaptioner (Mac/Windows) is a commercial application for creating and editing captions. MovieCaptioner works by repeating a 4-5 second snippet of the video to ensure it is captioned accurately.
Telestream’s CaptionMaker (Windows) and MacCaption (Mac) are professional-level tools for creating captioned and subtitled videos. They have a steeper learning curve compared to the other tools shared on this page.
Most services, including YouTube, allow you to upload a caption file created with another tool. Instructions for uploading captions files are listed for the various video hosting services, along with their supported formats:
Audio Description Tools
YouDescribe is a free tool for adding audio description to existing YouTube videos. All that is needed to use YouDescribe is a microphone and a connection to the internet. Descriptions are added through a web interface (YouDescribe runs best in Google Chrome). They can be inline or extended. Inline descriptions are added into pauses in the video to make sure they don’t get in the way of the existing dialogue or narration. Sometimes there is not enough time in a pause to add a description that effectively explains what is happening in the video. In that case, an extended description can pause the video while the description plays back. The video will then resume after the extended description has been heard in its entirety.
YouDescribe is also a community for sharing and rating described videos. In addition to the YouDescribe website, an iOS YouDescribe app is available. Currently, the app only allows browsing and rating the videos on the YouDescribe site.
The Screenflow screen recording app has an option for using text to speech to add audio descriptions. To add a new description, choose Insert, Speech Clip and type the text to be converted into audio using one of the built-in text to speech voices.
Captioning and Description Services
Even with the best tools, captioning is still a time-consuming and often laborious process. If you have hours of video to caption, you many want to consider hiring a captioning service. These companies offer a range of captioning services, from transcription to translation into other languages and subtitling:
Some of these companies offer audio description services as well.
Artificial production of human speech, using special software and/or hardware.View in glossary